Showing posts with label Muslims in America. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Muslims in America. Show all posts

Thursday, February 23, 2017

What is Jihad, Seriously, Again??

"Please point me in the direction of a copy of quran and sharia that you believe is right. And I will see if it differs from those I have allready. No compulsion in religion Holy war is the duty of all moslems."

Someone wrote, the above and wants to know, What is Jihad?

The reply I wrote, follows below. If anyone has a better definition or explanation, please feel free to send me
an email or comment below, thankx. The comments are 'screened', like Muslims at an international airport, before posting, so it may take a while before you see your comment.

Reply:
No, there is no "Holy War". That's a Christian evangelical idea. Their words. Jihad simply means striving in the path of God. If someone builds schools, mosques, roads, wells, that's all charity that earns rewards for the person who donates to such projects. It is the best kind of charity, something that benefits for a long time.There are types of jihad, too. Fighting one's own desires, is also jihad. When many people talk about Islam or jihad, all they talk about is "unjust war". War in Islam is for defense.
The Battle of Badr and Battle of Uhud, the two most remembered battles didn't have many deaths or casualties compared to many other wars. The pagans or the Muslims had to go. God favored the Muslims in the end, and Medina was established as a Muslim capital. It took Muhammad, over twenty years of preaching but most of the Arab pagans converted after that. Mekkah was a bloodless victory, in that everyone surrendered, and only the criminals were not released (there was actually one man who went into the Kaabah to escape and he was killed).
The head leader, Abu Jahal had died, and some of the others had already converted before the Fateh al Mekkah, that day, so the rest of their tribe soon followed, like Khalid Ibn Walid, who later converted, but Abu Sufyan another famous person had converted before that, and his wife was HInd, a woman who had hired an assassin to kill the Prophet's uncle Hamza. Despite this, they converted of their own free will when God willed. And became good Muslims.
Another case in point is the Jews and hypocrites in Medina who sided with them, after declaring their Islam, which people always bring up. Why were Jews killed in Medina or evicted? Because they were traitors. Do you want traitors who attack you to be given a free pass?? Do you only HATE Muslims but LOVE traitors?? No. War is just at certain times. Americans will "never forget" 911 but they forgot Iraq's innocent children very quickly. (SOMETIMES SOME) Americans and (SOMETIMES SOME)Christians are some of the worst hypocrites alive today. Muslims don't say that war isn't justified, but they believe that killing innocents is forbidden.
If some Muslims do that, they are the worst criminals. STOP saying (not you personally) that Muslims never say anything when terrorist attacks occur. We are against terrorism and killing of innocents, but when we say that, who is listening?? Oh. No one.. Obviously you still believe the lies about Islam or you wouldn't be asking about "No compulsion in religion". Don't be lazy and do some of your own reading. One book which is pretty good is "The Sealed Nectar". It won't cost you an arm and a leg. It is a biography of the Prophet Muhammad, and tells a lot about the battles, including Badr and Uhud, and why the Jews (traitors) were killed. It won a prize for the best biography in a contest, and was written by an Indian Muslim scholar and translated into English. There are many hadiths showing how kind and generous the Prophet Muhammad was. His character is pure and good, but non-Muslims want to make his character vile and evil. God forbid we should not defend him.
There is no translation that will do justice to the Quran, not just because it's Arabic, but because translators are human beings, and other languages also aren't as great as the Quranic Arabic. English, especially, is a young language, and you can see how it is being destroyed today. But there are some translations that are better than others. The Yusuf Ali one was edited because it had bigger problems than some others.
The Bible has many verses that must be embarrassing for Christians, some people say the same thing about Hadiths. Well, the hadiths aren't the word of God. (There are Hadiths Qudsi, which are God's words revealed to Muhammad, but not part of the Quran). But the majority of hadiths/sayings or traditions are not God's words, and also they were written and compiled after a long time. So they are more like what the Bible is in terms of how long after the events they were collected into books. The bible is also not God's word, so that explains why there are a lot of wrong things in it. No offence to people who read it to study it and get some good out of it. Cherry picking verses is the past-time of the non-Muslims. They do it with their own book and with the Quran (translation of the meaning of the Quran). But many people still say it is one of the best today (if you get the edited version). Learning Arabic is impossible for most people. But it is different when you know some Arabic and can read the original. That being said, the problem isn't even which translation but that people read with a closed mind, and there's no 'medicine' for that, except to ask God to open your heart and mind. Shariah is Islamic law, there is only one "islamic law". There are colleges that teach Usul Fiqh, jurisprudence. They will teach about the way to understand and apply laws. You know, stuff I haven't studied indepth.
There are many non-Muslims in Muslim majority states and they are not all fighting each other. Muslims work with non-Muslims here. We have a fairly peaceful country. The government is fair, and people are free to live and work. There is also one of the oldest Catholic Churches in the ME in our country (I am a citizen now too, as are many people who got their citizenship in the past couple of decades).
Just like any other person studies law, it is studied in Muslim countries, and also some other countries today. There is ijtihad, which is consensus of opinion, where a question is something the scholars today may not know about, such as things that never happened in the past, or for which there is no ruling. In law this is like looking for precedents, and if there aren't any then you derive an opinion from looking at the whole body of works on that subject and using their brains. Judges can be wrong, also when making judgments, and this is not denied. But Islamic law lays a lot of emphasis on proofs, and circumstantial evidence isn't emphasized. Even if a man is found with a knife in his hand at the scene of a stabbing death, doesn't prove his guilt, for example. There was such a case and the judge makes sure that he gets to the truth, if possible, or else the person can't be convicted of murder. In a very old case which happened, a man was actually found not guilty, because it turned out he confessed because he thought none would believe him anyway if he told the truth. He had come upon a murder scene, grabbed the weapon and then been found by people. Later, a man actually confessed, because he was afraid that he would be responsible for the murder of the victim plus the unjust killing of the person who confessed to the killing. I guess stranger things have happened. There *is* no compulsion in religion, so just go about your life like you always have if you have no interest in learning about Islam. Men are responsible for the expenses even when women work. That doesn't mean women marry men for their money, like many people say. Many non-Muslim women also are converting to Islam here, and also men are converting to Islam. There is no forced conversion. People are free to live and work, and they are free to worship wherever they are able to do that. In Canada, Muslims often pray at work, on their break, and it's not against the law. Why do people think freedom of religion is such a difficult concept??
Good day.

I THINK THIS IS ADDED LATER? :

I live in Bahrain, and it's fine, people have recreation and all the many things that they have back home, even many of the same foods, restaurants and fast food places, they may have a church (it varies in the ME from country to country). Not every Christian denomination has a church obviously. But it isn't the responsibility of a government to give land away for every church that some people want. I think the same goes of the masjids (mosques) in non-Muslim countries.I don't object to laws that are meant to protect people, and countries have a right to make such laws. But there are also laws against wrongful oppression of immigrants, etc. It is not only fair, but required that governments treat all their citizens equally and punish the wrongdoers, but not wrongfully convict innocent people or treat people who are not criminals like criminals. All governments, if they abide by the humanitarian laws, will treat citizens and also immigrants, or visa workers with kindness, justice and secure their peaceful existence and human dignity. Unfortunately,that's not always the case, is it? Islam has human rights, and even animal rights. These are binding in the Islamic texts, and are obvious.



[Jane Dughatir] Thanks for reading! Have a nice day/evening :)

(EDITS are in round brackets: when I probably insulted many ppl already I was informed by a friend about the error/mistake and corrected my wrong sentence. I have already apologized on social media. #clickbait #racism)

Monday, March 31, 2014

A WomanTells Us The Real Reason

• Diamond Draw • a minute ago

Almost all the Muslims I know have kids, regardless of the perceived intelligence, IQ, education and work backgrounds. So, they will have enough intelligent children to supply the world with geniuses someday if you don't want to. You don't have to take my word for it, just watch what happens in the next century.


Diamond Draw • 5 minutes ago

#1, a child is an 'it'. Enough said. The rest of the post is a waste of time and energy.

But you should have known that. Intelligent people make bad choices, they smoke more, etc. And they waste words and their precious time on the internet, just like other less intelligent people do.

#3, who raised an intelligent person, who then doesn't want children? The dumb teachers at the schools you attended, and how did you ever manage to get a BA or BS, when your professors barely had time to get to class (Just as likely to skip classes as any bubble gum chewing idiot teenager.)

#6, no time for kids because it take so much more energy to wash a couple of empty cans and recycle or reuse the little you do without children, while people with children manage to do all that and onehundred time more efficiently, if they are serious about it. They are more organized than you, which is what intelligent people are lacking, and more motivated, too. Mothers care about the environment too. Who was the American woman who broke the story about pollution and got the biggest settlement for victims in history, at the time? She had a kid or two.

# 7, the world is crowded, but America is going to be populated by more and more children of male sperm donors, who apparently can be the biological father of as many as ten thousand children, who are in effect all closely related.

Good luck with your National IQ in the next century, Miss America.

#8, Oprah has never had children, but she is always struggling with her weight, because often older women will get thyroid and other problems, whether they work out or not, which will affect their health. Many moms are not overweight. Americans are generally obese, despite that they have parks, oceans and seas and pools to swim in, sidewalks and boardwalks to stroll, and bicycle paths, unlike many other countries which don't. When one's child is in school, mom can take advantage of that, as a stay at home mom for six months or a year, to benefit her health and mind.

But you won't because children are too much of a bother and you say you are just too selfish.

How ever did you get a degree and manage to study, when there are so few hours in a day? All study and no play makes Jill a dull girl. But maybe she used to cut class, or her professors did, which gave her enough opportunity to go to the pub and have a drink and a couple of cigarettes? We know, studies show that intelligent people smoke more, and probably they drink more too. And University profs are notorious for skipping class, or giving some of the responsibilities for teaching to a TA.

So that's why we don't have kids. Because the time, the money, and the effort involved. It is much easier to sit in one's underwear and hire someone to wash all those dishes, when you are a single person or a small family of two.

This is the other real reason, fear of failure.

Recently Revised, there were some spelling and grammar issues, lol. Because I wrote it very quickly online.



Thursday, January 23, 2014

What it means to have a festival

I'll be sharing more older posts for the rest of January, sharing more comments from Google+ and tying into Islamic subjects that are of interest to the wider public.
Can't think of much off the top of my head, except the writing I've saved onto the home PC, for the moment, but I'm sure I can come up with other interesting original things to say soon. Insha Allah.

Today, "What It Means To Have A Festival" about the problems at a cultural event held in the US, which had (I'm guessing, educatedly) both Arab Christians and Arab Muslims, and many non Arab Americans.
Probably some bigotry or hate on both sides who were involved.

More bitmaps for readers, about the blog, comments and stats. Also bitmaps from Twitter, which are a new thing on the blog I'm introducing and will try to do more of in the future as well.

Since I can't comment on google+ these days, I have other ways to get around that by sharing on the blog, but probably there is a solution to that; also, readers comments welcome on the blog. I have commented myself here, so don't see why others can't or are unable. Maybe that's not so?


Also, photos and video this week.



Comments on blogger


Wednesday, February 13, 2013

Promotion - teach Islam with Yusuf Estes original "copyrighted" material

Islamnewsroom.com

This is an exclusive from the original website of Yusuf Estes, the best original argument for why Islam is the most Peaceful religion on Earth today. Don’t be fooled. Read on. Read the entire article, may Allah/God make your heart at ease with this religion and its people. Peace.

(Original version follows)                                                                                                                  J. D-N


What Does Islam Say?

Does it say 'Kill Infidels?' (no)

From "Answering Attacks Against Islam" - by yusuf estes


Question:

How [Do]We Answer Harsh Question and attacks against Islam?

Answer: Begin with the Name of Allah - and ask Him to send peace and blessings upon Muhammad, peace be upon him. And Remember "Allahu 'Alim" - it is only Allah who is the True Knower of all Things.

Someone said, "Your Quran says to kill all the Jews and Christians.."

This is absolutely not true and it is quite easy to prove.

The Quran still exists today just as it did at the time of the prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him. You see, he never did learn how to read or write, so he memorized the entire Quran from the angel Gabriel (Jibril in Arabic) and then he passed on this recition (Quran) to his companions and they in turn passed it on to the next generation and this practice continues even today, reciting by memory and then passing it on to the next generations. And by the way, it is exactly the same from anywhere it is recited in the world.

We know the Quran orders believers to fight in combat against those who are the oppressers, aggressors and terrorists and those who are assaulting and killing the innocent men, women and chldren. But it gives out clear orders - NOT TO Fight against those who are not fighting against you...

Now here is an example of how you might answer those folks with the harsh questions:

First say, "Thank you for your interest in Islam and the Muslims"

Continue, "It is our duty and privilege to present the truth and proof about Islam and what it represents. We desire to clear up misconceptions and misunderstandings about Islam to help others see the true message that came with all of the prophets from Adam, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad, peace be upon them all."

Now be sure to mention this important point:

"The message is: Laa elaha illa lah (none has the right to be worshipped except Allah)."

Now say,

"And before I begin to answer the question, I would like to ask you a question - 'If you hear something you like in the answer or something that really makes sense to you - then are you prepared(sic) to accept the message of worshipping your Lord without any partners?"

"After all, Islam is really all about this one subject anyway."

Then go to the next important area (misconceptions):

"Now let us correct some mistakes in the 'question' itself. There is not such a meaning in the Quran, ordering or even permitting the Muslims to ever attack innocent people whether they are Christians, Jews, or any other faith for that matter.

Combat is only ordered against those who are attacking or killing the innocent Muslims or fighting against the established Muslim state.

Read...

________________________________________________________

Now here is the answer -

The word used most often in Quran, that is so often mistranslated as kill; slay; or slaughter is not jihad, it is qital and if you look to the Arabic, you will quickly understand this word in today's usage would clearly be combat.

Naturally, just as here in the U.S. we must stand up for righteousness and strive to prevent oppression, aggression and tyranny. This is the proper usage and understanding for this term, as you will discover while passing through the tafseer and explanations by top scholars today.

Scholars of Quran tell us the verses dealing with this topic are specific and not intended to imply a general meaning for just anyone to decide to go around combating non-Muslims. The early Muslims had been driven out of their homes and turned out into the desert to starve. After finally, relocating in Medina, verses came in Quran instructing them to make hajj (pilgrimage) back to Makkah. Finding their way blocked and after several years of making agreements and treaties that the others continually broke, the Muslims were at last, told they could now fight in combat against the tyrants who had so horribly mistreated and abused them in the past. However, this would only be acceptable to Allah if they remained within very specific limitations. The word "qital" in Arabic in this instance refers to "combat" rather than what some have used "kill" because the word "kill" is far to general, while the word "combat" appropriately describes what is intended by the usage in this passage. Allah Knows Best.

It should also be noted the usage of the word "fitnah" in the same verse denotes a horrible condition, not unlike what we find today when there is terrorism and tyranny against the moral and just society at large. It would be easy to properly understand the meaning as, "Engage them in combat, even killing them, until the state of "fitnah" (terrorism) no longer exists in the society and people are free to worship Allah by their choice."

We can see these verse are not designed to promote terrorism, but rather these are very orders from Above to the Muslims to be the first of those who stand out aggressively against all forms of terrorism and oppression.

Once this is in place, there really isn't a question anymore, due to the necessity as we see today, to prevent and subdue enemies of freedom, liberty and justice. In other words, we could easily say Allah ordered believers in the Quran to wage combat against terrorism - 14 centuries ago. And the "struggle against oppression, terrorism and tyranny" in the Arabic language, it is called, "Jihad."

I tell them,

"Islam declared the WAR ON TERRORISM - over 1,400 years ago!"

________________________________________________________

Details: read explanation of Quran for verses, 2:189-193 at: www.QTafsir.com

It is time to visit our website and download or bookmark our free copy of translation of Quran... First thing you do is download the Quran from our site at:

www.allahsquran.com/goodies/free.php
Then go to the verse in question and read the Arabic, then the English, then the transliteration (making the sounds with English letters). Then compare the meaning to what you have pronounced.

Here are a few of the misquoted verses:

Verses containing the word "Qital" (fighting in combat)

2.190 Fight (in combat) in the way of Allah those who fight you but do not transgress.

2.191 And kill them (in combat) wherever you overtake them and expel them from wherever they have expelled you, and

2.193 Fight them (in combat) until there is no more 'fitnah' [agression, oppression and terrorism] and worship is allowed for Allah.

2.216 Fighting (in combat) has been enjoined upon you while it is hateful to you. But perhaps you hate a thing and it is good for you; and

2.217 They ask you about the sacred month – about fighting (in combat) therein. Say, "Fighting therein is great [sin],

2.244 And fight (in combat) in the cause of Allah and know that Allah is Hearing and Knowing.

2.246 Have you not considered the assembly of the Children of Israel after [the time of] Moses when they said to a prophet of theirs, "Send to us a king, and we will fight (in combat) in the way of Allah"?

3.13 Already there has been for you a sign in the two armies which met [in combat in Badr] – one fighting (in combat)

3.111 They will not harm you except for [some] annoyance. And if they fight you (in combat) , they will show you their backs;

3.142 Or do you think that you will enter Paradise while Allah has not yet made evident those of you who fight (in combat) in His cause and

3.156 O you who have believed, do not be like those who disbelieved and said about their brothers when they traveled through the land or went out to fight (in combat) , "If they

3.167 And that He might make evident those who are hypocrites. For it was said to them, "Come, fight (in combat) in the way of Allah or

4.74 So let those fight (in combat) in the cause of Allah who sell the life of this world for the Hereafter. And he who fights in the cause of Allah

4.75 And what is [the matter] with you that you do not fight (in combat) in the cause of Allah

4.76 Those who believe fight (in combat) in the cause of Allah, and those who disbelieve fight in the cause of taghūt. So fight against the allies of Satan.

4.77 Have you not seen those who were told, "Restrain your hands [from fighting] and establish prayer and give zakah"? But then when fighting (in combat) was ordained for them, at once a party of them feared men as they fear Allah or with

4.84: So fight (in combat), in the cause of Allah; you are not held responsible except for yourself. And encourage the believers

4.90: Except for those who take refuge with a people between yourselves and whom is a treaty or those who come to you, their hearts strained at [the prospect of] fighting you (in combat) or fighting their own people..

4.94: O you who have believed, when you go forth [to fight (in combat)] in the cause of Allah, investigate; and do not say to one who gives you [a greeting of] peace "You are not a believer,"

5.24 : They said, "O Moses, indeed we will not enter it, ever, as long as they are within it; so go, you and your Lord, and fight (in combat). Indeed,

8.39 : And fight them (in combat) until there is no fitnah [agression, oppression & terrorism] and [until] the religion, all of it, is for Allah. And if they cease – then indeed, Allah is Seeing of what they do.

• 8.65: O Prophet, urge the believers to combat. If there are among you twenty (who are) steadfast, they will overcome two hundred...

• 8.74: But those who have believed and emigrated and fought in the cause of Allah and those who gave shelter and aided - it is they who are the believers, truly. For them is forgiveness and noble provision.

• 8.75: And those who believed after (the initial emigration) and emigrated and fought (in combat) with you - they are of you…

• 9.5: And when the sacred months have passed, then engage the pagans in mortal combat wherever you find them and capture them and desiege them and sit in wait for them at every place of ambush. But if they should repent, establish salat (proper worship) and give charity, let them (go) on their way.

• 9.12: And if they break their oaths after their treaty and defame your religion, then fight the leaders of disbelief, for indeed, there are no oaths (sacred) to them; (fight them) so the will stop.

• 9.13: Would you not fight a people who broke their oaths and determined to expel the Messenger, and they had begun (attacking) you the first time? Do you fear them? …

• 9.14: Fight them; Allah will punish them by your hands and will disgrace them and give you victory over them…

• 9.29: Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture – [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled.

• 9.36: Indeed, the number of months with Allah is twelve [lunar] months in the register of Allah [from] the day He created the heavens and the earth; of these, four are sacred. That is the correct religion, so do not wrong yourselves during them. And fight against the disbelievers collectively as they fight against you collectively.

In each case, the use of the words in English for battle, combat, fight and so on - is actually only one word in Arabic - 'qital'.

Perhaps the best way to understand a single word in today's English would be 'combat' or 'military combat' or even 'mortal combat'. (like Jihad, also, though qital is specific to combat, and not used to mean broadly "any" striving, such as "striving with their wealth and lives" - DD)

In all the cases it is to be understood as military engagement in battle or war.
(Reference: www.AllahsQuran.com/read in the search box, type the word 'fight')

Now notice the actual word 'jihad' - for example in chapter and verse - 9.44 Those who believe in Allah and the Last Day would not ask permission from you to be excused from 'striving' with their wealth and their lives. And Allah is Knowing of those who fear him.

Check out www.AboutJihad.com

We pray to Allah to make it easy for all of us to find the correct meanings and teachings of Islam and allow us to share Islam with others, and forgive our mistakes and grant us His Paradise, ameen.

Permission to copy & distribute (with limits)

Yusuf Estes says: "I give full permission to use any and all of my writings and recordings without copyrights for anyone who is engaged in presenting the true message of the peace of Islam, provided it is done without charge and there are no alterations, additions or deletions. (signed) Yusuf Estes, February 22, 2012"

Answers: www.JustAskislam.com

Free Quran: www.FreeQuran.org

http://www.linkstoislam.com/ (another good website by Yusuf Estes - DD)


If You Care - You Share

COMMENTS

FACEBOOK - TWITTER - Chatrooms



Monday, February 11, 2013

Stealth Jihad

I t seems that many people don't know Muslims, nor have ever spoken or dealt with regular Muslims.
I want to quickly , and first tell everyone, reassure people that Muslims, who are supposed to be honest and truthful, don't lie. Sure, sometimes even Muslims might fib about their weight, or if asked:"are your eyes really blue?"  Might reply: "Yes" and they are telling a "fib". In Islam though, there is no permissible "fibbing", there is lying to be kind, or a peacemaker. Meaning, lying is only permitted when one wants to make peace with his close friend or family member, so he says something which is like a "white lie". For example, a lie to avoid anger of a loved-one e.g. "I didn't mean to eat your cake" ;"I thought it was left over and nobody wanted it."
You can probably think of better white lies than I can. "I don't think you're fat at all" or maybe,  
"I hope the kids all look like you", lol.

Tariq Ramadan:

Tariq Ramadan seems like a nice guy, he's respected as well. He has an important position as head of Islamic studies, at a University in London. Oxford? I mean he is quite benign seeming. But R. Spencer wrote an entire book about Stealth Jihad, or another book about Tariq Ramadan. I mean, its like "you're damned if you do, and you're damned if you don't", to quote some one who said that. Because some Muslims are very outspoken, they are easy targets. And then, when Tariq Ramadan gave charity to a group and that group gave charity to Hamas, Tariq Ramadan became "suspect". Spencer, says, though I am suspicious of his motives for doing so, that Tariq R. is like a "sleeper", y'know, planning on something "evil", e.g. "jihad" and if you've seen the documentary film "Jihad in America", you might not be able to sleep at night with Tariq in Town. I'm joking of course.

So we have to learn to be more careful in our remarks, or where we give charity.
So my advice with regards to the incident described above, is that we should give charity at home or to people we know, such as needy neighbours or we can give food and clothing, instead of cash. We have to protect ourselves too. And Muslims know that we have a big PR problem, we have to work harder to build trust, and also be as honest as possible.

Sometimes people (other Muslims) might suggest that we should not blog or comment to ignorant people about Islam. I know it is difficult and we are not all scholars, or well read, or even have the time or (sometimes) the sheer energy required - are you drained at the end of the day? Do you dread going to your inbox to read the mail? But take heart that someone somewhere is learning something new, be it a Muslim or a non-Muslim, or someone is at least willing to engage in a positive normal conversation. So much on the internet revolves around the person of the Prophet, and misconceptions about Islam in general.

Tariq Ramadan is able to enter the US now, after having been banned for 5 years. But he is  not a stealth Jihadist, nor a "sleeper" of any sort. We wish him well.

Yusuf Estes tonite:

Brother Yusuf Estes, a beloved and consciencious Muslim is in Bahrain on the last leg of his Bahrain tour, the third night is tonite (Revised - this is an older draft, Yusuf  Estes was here, is no longer here.) at the Bait al Quran where he will be speaking. Probably about now. So, go to live streaming from his website (I'm not sure which one, maybe www.shareislam.net for more on the activity he has prepared for tonight's audience.

Monday, December 10, 2012

More about Fatawas without Knowledge – Part Two

Another example of a few years ago, was the Muslim man in France, who told his sister to shave her head because she couldn’t (or was fearful of) wear(ing) the hiijab (Muslim women’s head cover), there.

At the time it was a big issue, especially because she appeared in public, crying that she had to resort to removing her hair (voluntarily) yet (obviously) hated her actions.

But from the purely Islamic viewpoint, this ill-conceived ‘Islamic ruling’ by her brother was in fact based on wrong knowledge, or motivations. Did he tell her to shave her hair because 1) Jewish women sometimes shave their hair, or used to in the past and wear wigs to cover their head, in lieu of wearing a head cover similar to hiijab, in fact what is a “head scarf”, for religious reasons?

2) Was the brother motivated by the urge to get attention for his sister’s cause, instead attracting public scrutiny, which seemed to have worked less in his favor (and hers) than more in his or her favor?

From the Islamic Viewpoint:

Our actions must be purely for the sake of Allah

Our actions must be done based on proper knowledge

If these conditions are lacking, then the correct Islamic behavior will not be forthcoming.

The solution:

Wouldn’t it have been better for the girl not to shave her hair, and to try covering some other way?

Wouldn’t it have been better to keep her intention to wear the hiijab, when she was ready, but not shave her head (because that is also unlawful in Islam)?

To try to avoid one sin, the brother allowed his sister to commit two sins!

Niya:

Intentions are very important in Islam. Without the proper intentions, seemingly good actions can actually earn someone sin; because if someone does an action for the sake of Allah’s pleasure only, then it is rewardable, even one hundred times, or more; but if one does the same action to appear good in front of the people, then the same is actually punishable, and will not be accepted by Allah in the least. In fact, these kinds of people are possible hypocrites, or have a characteristic of hypocrisy.

As to committing a sin, such as removing the head covering, which is one of the few public actions Muslim women are obliged to follow according to the Qur’an and Sunna, it is less dangerous, perhaps than trying to invent new things into the religion (bid’aa) or circumvent Islamic objections (proper knowledge) such as what happened when the brother advised his sister to shave her hair, without consulting with an (real) Islamic scholar.

Muslim Community Values

While, it is praiseworthy to wear the hiijab, or other Islamic clothing, such as a covering Jilbab for the regular clothing (like a ‘manteau’), it is often the central issue about Muslim women which gets negative media attention. Perhaps Muslims, as a community should begin to shift the attention away from the hiijab, if possible, to more urgent community issues, such as the need for better Islamic education for their children. This education, in some places, through the funding of separate schools, for Muslims is now a reality. At conferences, specially about this milestone, the Muslim community in the West has heard that a generation of Muslims speaking fluent Arabic, memorizers of the ‘hadiths’ (traditions), and with the necessary skills and knowledge in modern subjects, studying in Universities in all the various fields of study, are ready to take the stage, as the foremost models for True Islam in their society.

While, we also have to worry about the hiijab issue, because “our daughters” in school, especially young girls, need to confront this as well, it is a much more personal issue than the issue of education.

I don’t know if this makes any sense, to most people; but for many women in the west, hiijab is no longer a ‘stumbling block’ or a ‘problem’. Many women in the public eye now wear jilbab and hiijab, or even a cloak similar to a ‘burqa’, such as the Middle Eastern ‘abaya’ (but which does not cover the face, only the body).

Therefore, do we need to keep at the hiijab as a fundamental right? Or should we/are we able to address other issues, such as education (funding for private Islamic schools, or independent schools, such as could be modeled on some schools in the Middle East, where Islamic education is a subject, as well as languages), or whatever type of schools they desire, as a community? These could be institutions which require the Islamic dress code, or ones which reserve it as a fundamental right, but without insisting on it, because hiijab in the west is very much a private matter.

Note: The Muslim community in the West, unlike the European community, hasn’t seen the pervasive racism or hate that Muslims living in Europe have; with laws banning the veil, or even banning hiijab.

Freedom of Religion:

When the West can admit that Muslims there are good citizens, and as a result of equal rights, which proves to be a plus not a minus, then this model community of which Muslims can be proud, hopefully can be the first example of True Islam, perhaps in the world. It will be an Islamic Revival, starting in the heart of Western civilization, it is hoped.

In future, to prove that Muslims were right in the belief that Islam is for all time and place, a Universal religion, for humankind.

Farfetched;

Unlikely or perhaps something people who have not experienced the power of religious conversion in their own life cannot fathom. As a community, since 9-11 Muslims have shown patience and perseverance. Their exemplary behavior, even in the face of government policy against freedom of belief and in some cases, suffering and persecution, should be understood and remembered. They were able despite suspicion to stand shoulder to shoulder with their neighbors of different faiths and backgrounds, to pray for the safety of their communities, or lend a helping hand, wherever they could, as well as during natural disaster, such as the flooding of years past in New Orleans.

A positive outlook for a positive future (lies ahead).

Democracy, (not to be confused with secularism, which is the absence of religion) much more than the European model of Multiculturalism, has helped Muslims to integrate, while retaining their fundamental right of religious freedom.